If you mix a little bit of "Austin Powers" with some material from "The Game" -- two films from earlier this year -- you'd come up with "The Man Who Knew Too Little." Featuring one of our favorite comedic actors, Bill Murray, you can't fault this feature for having elements of both films since it was most likely well into production before those others were released. Still, the similarities are there. Like "Powers," this film spoofs the spy movie series, but it doesn't have as much silly fun as that movie, although it does include a great deal of similar "mod" music in its soundtrack.
Its plot is much closer to "The Game," however, where a brother pays for his sibling to have some fun in a make believe world that turns out to be anything but that. Unlike that film, though, this one goes solely for the laughs and Murray is the perfect actor to be featured in such a role. Often cast as the disheveled and slightly confused lead, Murray expertly plays this character who unknowingly flirts with real danger while being game and really getting into his dramatic spy role.
Murray's career has had its share of brilliant hits and a few thuds. Luckily -- for us and him -- this one falls closer to the hit side, especially when compared to his last film, "Larger Than Life" (the elephant movie that bombed with critics and audiences alike). This film puts him back into a more familiar groove, and he seems to be enjoying himself in the role. Although neither his performance nor this film is his funniest -- those honors still go to 1993's "Groundhog Day," this is definitely his best performance -- in his funniest film -- since then.
Unfortunately the film never quite feels like it's running on all cylinders and thus never fully takes off into comic lunacy. The elements are all in place, and the script is rather clever in utilizing its characters' dual interpretations of what's occurring while also delivering double entendres. Yet it feels somewhat reserved -- as if Murray were held back by a creative leash that didn't want him, or the movie, to push the limits too far. That's too bad because the potential of this film is great, but never fully realized.
Beyond Murray's restraint, the other problem lies with the supporting cast. While they perform adequately for such a film, many of the characters are just cardboard fillers or stereotypical villains (unlike Mike Meyers funny take as the villain in "Austin Powers"), and their sole function is to play the "straight man" to Murray. Since Murray's not fully unleashed, however, we need to see more humor from these characters to take up the slack. Yet they don't provide that, and the film consequently remains grounded.
Don't get us wrong -- the movie has its share of funny moments, but none of them fall into the knee slapping, "stop cuz my stomach hurts from laughing so hard" category. Obviously much of the humor originates from us knowing the "real" danger that Murray faces, while he obliviously thinks it's all just part of the play. For example, an early scene involving Murray thinking two thieves are just actors -- while they're anything but -- is moderately humorous, but it should have been played much better.
The rest of the humor comes from the plot's double meanings, where Murray thinks everyone is acting and what they say is just dialogue. Conversely, while they think what he says is profound, he's simply being rather matter of fact. For instance, Wallace tells some spies that he's "going to fire up some big ambassadors" near midnight, and the spies think he's on to their plan, when in reality he's referring to some cigars he and his brother plan to smoke later. There's a lot of other such similar material that will prod a chuckle and/or make you smile from its cleverness -- and a lot of it is quite fun -- but most of it's not hilarious.
The ending provides an obvious tie-in for a sequel, where Murray will have yet another opportunity to misunderstand the plot he's stumbled into, while everyone else will think he's the best spy the world has ever known. Whether they make the sequel will depend on this film's success, and unfortunately it's running right into the middle of a very crowded pre-holiday playing field, so the odds aren't the best.
Still, if you're a big Bill Murray fan you'll love this film, and you should -- it's his best in several years. On the other hand, if you're just looking for a good comedy, this one will probably work for you, but it's certainly not going to be the funniest thing you see this year. While it's clever, cute, and occasionally sparks a laugh, this film isn't quite as good as it thinks it is, or should have been. Thus, we give "The Man Who Knew Too Little" a 6 out of 10.