For the most part, lead characters in romantic comedies come in two forms, those who are pursuing romance, and those who are avoiding it. The first group actively seeks out relationships, partners, and they're incurable romantics. The second group isn't looking for love, avoids relationships like the plague, and generally hates it when others try to fix them up. "The Matchmaker" offers us both, and who better than Janeane Garofalo ("The Truth About Cats & Dogs") to headline the second group. Not that she's not a lovely person and may be in a perfectly fine relationship in real life, but she often portrays characters in her standup comedy routines and in her films that haven't had luck with finding a partner and romance in general. It's off that portrayal that the plot of this movie hinges, and it works perfectly well as she ends up stuck in a foreign land's matchmaking festival. Obviously, the comic possibilities are numerous and the film takes advantage of many of them, but nicely plays a great deal of it low key. Of course, a great deal of your enjoyment of this film will depend on your appreciation or liking of Garofalo. Her dry, comic style and often irritated, cynical attitudes have a unique quality to them and while some think she's very funny, others often find her a bit too bristly for their liking. We fall into the first group and think that those characteristics fit in perfectly with her no-nonsense demeanor. Her character's "woman from the big city" attitude and the fact that she doesn't want to get hooked up with anyone are of course her weaknesses that the film will exploit, and much of the comedy that follows results from just that.
Yet as funny as Garofalo is, the supporting characters are even funnier. From one-time character appearances to recurring ones, these "background" people provide a great deal of the film's biggest laughs. Much like Alan Parker's brilliant "The Commitments" (1991) -- the hilarious film about Irish musicians -- the characters here don't make any pretenses about hiding their true emotions, and the way that they quickly, and often absentmindedly, blurt out their thoughts is quite hilarious. Sanders is great as the fence straddling, democratic Senator from Massachusetts, and his oblivious nature provides for some humorous material. In one scene he's hyped up about his future potential and says, "If we play our cards right, I'll end up like Kennedy." Thinking for a moment about what happened to JFK, he adds, "...(but) alive." Beyond it's setting, the film doesn't offer up a great deal of anything new for this genre. It does seem to have a little more depth than most films of this type, though, and does have some heartfelt, non-romantic moments. But it's romance that everyone wants and this film delivers. Of course everyone knows that Marcy will become disillusioned with her big city job and boss, and that she and Sean will get together by the story's end (it is a romantic comedy after all). In this genre it's usually the journey to that point, however, that's most of the fun and this film provides a pleasant and scenic road upon which to take that journey. For those who like romantic comedies, this is pretty much a sure thing. For those who like films with a little more depth, this one also delivers that. It will bring a smile to your face, an occasional tear to your eye, and that general warm, fuzzy feeling that proves that the film has hit its spot. We enjoyed this movie a great deal and give it a 7.5 out of 10.