Proving once again that it's difficult to transform a three or four-minute skit into a feature length film, "A Night at the Roxbury" is sporadically funny at best, but mightily strains to fill its brief eighty minute runtime.
Based on a currently running, and somewhat humorous skit on TV's "Saturday Night Live," this film follows in a long line of skits that have landed with varying results as feature movies. For every "Blues Brothers" and "Wayne's World," there's "It's Pat" and "Stuart Saves His Family," so it should come as no surprise that the filmmakers and Paramount Studios are willing to hedge their bets on the film's apparent 50/50 chances.
The problem is, however, when compared to the skits that were successful, there's practically nothing here with which to work from the original. While the pumping, toe-tapping rhythms of the main song, "What Is Love?" can inspire nearly anyone to bob their head in unison to the beat, the original skit is pretty threadbare beyond that.
The only real fun of the recurring TV sketch is watching the guest stars (such as Jim Carrey, Alec Baldwin and others) join the two losers in their pathetically funny behavior, as they pump their heads in unison, confusedly point to themselves and each other trying to figure which of them another person's referring to, and then bouncing that person back and forth between them.
Unfortunately, there's not much more to the movie, and the supplementary plot and dialogue that exist are substandard even for a film like this. Feeling more like the ugly step cousin to "Wayne's World" and its goofy characters that also originated on "SNL," this film was bad enough to inspire/force many people in our audience to get up and leave the theater long before the conclusion -- something I haven't seen in quite a while.
The film's problems are multifaceted. As directed by John Fortenberry (Pauly Shore's "Jury Duty") from a script by Ferrell, Kattan, and Steve Koren, there's practically no plot -- something that's okay for a skit, but not a feature film -- and what's there is only meagerly funny at best. The best moments have the guys doing their normal schtick, but even that quickly wears thin as it offers nothing new from the original skit material.
Beyond that, we're supposed to find scenes where the brothers fight, attempt to bribe a doorman with pocket change, or primp as they prepare to go out for the evening as funny (the sight of them in their ultra tight fitting, shiny polyester shirts might elicit a lone giggle), but such scenes mostly fall flat. The same holds true for the brief "spoof" moments where scenes from "Say Anything," "Saturday Night Fever" and "Jerry Maguire" are easily recognized, but not executed in a way to make them as funny as they should have been.
Equally problematic are the characters themselves. Somewhat similarly constructed, but not as developed as the Wayne and Garth characters from the "Wayne's World" movies (something you'd never have thought possible until you see this film), their one-note creations consequently have a limited comedic arsenal with which to work.
Will Farrell and Chris Kattan are gifted comedians, but lack that extra spark needed to make their characters jump from the screen. For instance, while both sets of characters (from this film and "Wayne's World") are nervous or partially oblivious to/blinded by the forward advances of the opposite sex, the Butabi brothers are considerably less amusing and/or charming than those guys from Aurora. Supporting cast members, such as Molly Shannon and Dan Hedaya, equally can't do much with their one-dimensionally created characters.
Although the film, like the skit, manages to exude a certain goofy charm, that alone can't carry this picture, and we expect that this release will most likely make a quick beeline for the video stores. After all, when one of the brothers comments near the end that he loves the "What is Love" song and the other mentions that he's getting kind of sick of it, you know that's bad since the song's about the best thing the movie has to offer. We give "A Night At The Roxbury" a 2 out of 10.