A charming and talkatively witty picture, "I Went Down" has already become Ireland's biggest grossing domestic movie of all time. While it won't fare quite as well in the States, art house audiences looking for a smartly constructed movie that, yes, contains a shootout and car chase (proving that such an adjective can be confidently used with those elements), should be pleased by this little flick.
Playwright and stage director Conor McPherson makes his screenwriting debut with this film. Although his script isn't as cleverly hip as the similarly based and constructed films that Quentin Tarantino writes and helms (the pop/cultural references are all but absent), its more human qualities make it accessible in a different, but still accomplished way. While the dialogue won't tease and tantalize audiences, it's interesting and just offbeat enough to make things worthwhile.
Definitely a character-driven vehicle (much like the recent crime-based "Out of Sight), but with a bit more of a complex plot, the performers inhabiting the characters are anonymous enough not to bring any previous role baggage with them, thus giving the audience the feeling that they've stumbled across something fresh and original.
The leads, played by Brendan Gleeson ("The Butcher Boy," "Braveheart") as the amusingly short- tempered gangster and Peter McDonald (who makes his feature film debut) as the convict who hasn't even been out of prison for a day before getting caught up in this mess, are thoroughly delightful to watch. Working from what's essentially a road movie about two opposites who've been paired together, the actors take that somewhat overused cinematic design and flesh out their characters into real, and quite funny personas.
Bunny (the name itself evokes a chuckle considering the gruff and large character to whom it's attached) gets criminal performance anxiety when Git watches him, and easily but comically gets irritated at his criminal partner's naiveté. Git, on the other hand, and not being a true, hardened criminal (he did time for someone else's crime), wants to help Grogan and doesn't understand that the man may be bamboozling him.
Supporting performances from Peter Caffrey (who's appeared in some UK TV series) and Tony Doyle ("Circle of Friends") are decent as well. While Doyle isn't given much latitude with which to work within his typical mob boss character, Caffrey is quite funny as the world's most talkative hostage -- a behavior that drives Bunny crazy and provides for a funny moment when the fellows have Grogan in the backseat and are momentarily stopped by the police.
While the film never offers any hearty belly laughs, director Paddy Breathnach ("Ailsa") -- who makes his sophomore outing with this picture -- uses McPherson's script to elicit some rather humorous moments. For instance, upon covertly entering a house to retrieve Grogan from some gun-toting thugs, Bunny dons a traditional robbery ski-mask, but the one he gives Git has a completely open face. Not knowing any better, the novice criminal dons the incriminating disguise and looks quite silly sneaking through the home.
Other moments, such as a tied up hostage accidentally dropping the remote control -- thus forever leaving the TV on a droll algebra lesson program -- are also quite funny, as is the fact that Bunny can't ever steal a reliable vehicle, thus resulting in a succession of less than worthy vehicles.
While the film offers relatively nothing new to the criminal comedy caper, the characters are fresh enough and the Irish setting (complete with some occasional and unfortunately unintelligible accents) is different enough to give the film a novel feel. Featuring some fun characters who are inhabited by talented performers, and enough witty dialogue to liven up the proceedings, this is a decent, but certainly lightweight time at the movies. We give "I Went Down" a 6 out of 10.