Whenever a film has a special effects-generated character who's more engaging than his real-life counterparts, and uses its best gag in the opening sequence -- in this case, a clever spoof of what the Sojourner Rover might have seen had it gone just a little farther beyond Barnacle Bill (the rock) on its Mars Mission -- and then doesn't go anywhere but down from there, you know it and the audience are headed for trouble.
Such is the case with "My Favorite Martian," the big screen remake of the classic 1960's TV sitcom that starred Ray Walston and Bill Bixby. Much like Disney's other "mining" efforts -- such as the recent release of movies that rehash vintage films, TV shows or cartoons such as "Flubber" (from "The Absentminded Professor"), "That Darn Cat," "The Parent Trap" and "101 Dalmatians" to name a few -- this one doesn't capture the quaint charm of the original source material and consequently comes off as something that doesn't quite fully entertain the kids or their parents.
While I never watched enough of the original TV show to make a comparative analysis between it and this big-screen adaption, the highlight for those old enough in the audience to remember the original was the occasional appearance by Ray Walston, the original Martian, and some briefly clever ties between that series and this film.
Beyond that, however, this is some fluffy, lightweight stuff that thankfully passes by at a rather rapid clip. As such, at least it makes the film's lackluster and overall banal presentation slightly less irritating than it might have been.
Of course, Martians and other space aliens have been on the minds of the public ever since Orson Welles pulled his fabulous "War of the Worlds" radio stunt, and after "My Favorite Martian's" initial TV run, other series, such as "Mork and Mindy" and the still running "3rd Rock From the Sun" have taken the "aliens among us plot" and used it for great comic effect.
Unfortunately, this film is more interested in scatological humor (no further evidence need be presented of that than the sight of a large man's butt bearing down onto a toilet seat and several miniaturized characters) than the more refined, but still occasionally sophomoric observational material regarding the qualities and peculiarities of what it means to be human.
Despite -- or perhaps because of -- "3rd Rock's" success at cleverly showing how aliens deal with the human bodies they inhabit, the filmmakers here -- including director Donald Petrie ("Grumpy Old Men") and screenwriters Sherri Stoner and Deanna Oliver ("Casper") -- decided to forgo that vast goldmine of material (and thus any chance of entertaining the adults) in favor of decidedly less intelligent and more mundane bits. As such and despite a few moments of touching on that observational matter, "Uncle Martin" all too readily and easily accepts most everything about being human.
Instead, and much like the recent "Flubber" -- but without the presence of a Robin Williams type performer to carry the production -- this film seems more intent on showcasing its special effects than telling a fun or compelling story. While the "Zoot" spacesuit effect is rather good and provides for a few sparse jokes (as does a body falling apart sequence), some of the other effects look incredibly fake and superimposed onto the existing shots.
The performances are okay for the sort of film this is trying to be -- meaning that no attempt is made at resembling real people, but that's okay on its own level -- and there are enough recognizable faces (including Jeff Daniels, Daryl Hannah and Ray Watson) present to keep things moderately interesting.
As the new "Uncle Martin," Christopher Lloyd is okay, but kept reminding me of his "Doc Brown" character from the "Back to the Future" films, while model turned sometime actress Elizabeth Hurley ("Austin Powers") continues to prove that she has no problem with playing goofy characters.
Missing that observational humor and plenty of other "alien" moments to spoof (including the film series of that name, the goofy "alien autopsy" shows on the FOX network, and even "Close Encounters" and "The X-Files" that are ever so briefly hinted at, but then quickly abandoned), the film may please some kids with its body (and body parts) humor, but it's doubtful it will be a big enough hit to warrant the sequel possibility with which it so strongly closes. We give "My Favorite Martian" a 2.5 out of 10.