May (ANGELA BETTIS) is a young, loner woman who was ostracized as a child for having a lazy eye and thus grew up with her mother's doll as her only friend. Now fitted with contact lenses that have corrected that ocular problem, May wants to find a real friend, particularly since she's never touched the doll that's safely protected within its display case.
Polly (ANNA FARRIS), her animal hospital coworker, has set her lesbian sights on May, but the young woman is interested in Adam (JEREMY SISTO), an auto shop worker and student filmmaker. Although he initially doesn't even realize she's around, she eventually gets his attention and he's drawn to her unusual mannerisms and behavior.
Yet, when she gets a little too weird for even him, she suddenly finds herself without a friend or lover. And when a brief fling with Polly turns out not to be serious, May begins to go off the deep end, citing that people have beautiful parts, but that no one is the complete package. From that point on, she decides that if she can't find a friend or lover, she'll just have to go about making one.