[Screen It]

 

"THE PATRIOT"
(2000) (Mel Gibson, Heath Ledger) (R)

If you've come from our parental review of this film and wish to return to it, simply click on your browser's BACK button.
Otherwise, use the following link to read our complete Parental Review of this film.

QUICK TAKE:
Drama/Action: After a British officer kills one of his children, a reluctant American colonist and war veteran joins forces with the American militia to battle the British during the Revolutionary War.
PLOT:
It's 1776 and Benjamin Martin (MEL GIBSON) is an American colonist and recent widower trying to raise his seven children on his South Carolina estate. A veteran of the French and Indian War with a troubled past that still haunts him, Martin believes that King George's taxation without representation policy is wrong, but wants nothing to do with supporting a revolutionary war with the British.

Even so, a South Carolina assembly votes to have their state join the rebellion and Martin is unable to stop his oldest son, Gabriel (HEATH LEDGER) from enlisting. Hoping that his good friend and fellow war veteran Col. Harry Burwell (CHRIS COOPER) will watch over his son, Martin returns to his plantation and tries to get on with raising his family.

Yet, the forces under Gen. Cornwallis (TOM WILKINSON) soon take Charleston and the war looms closer. When a wounded Gabriel stumbles home and a battle literally breaks out in his front yard, Martin realizes he won't be able to escape the war. That becomes even more true when Col. William Tavington (JASON ISAACS) arrives and captures Gabriel, orders him to be hanged, and then shoots one of Martin's other sons as he tries to intervene.

Shocked and grieving over the sudden turn of events, Martin goes into warrior mode, and with the help of his two younger sons, ambushes a British unit and rescues Gabriel. Sending the rest of his kids to a plantation run by his sister-in-law, Charlotte Selton (JOELY RICHARDSON), Martin takes up arms against the British and is given command of the local militia. With the aid of French officer Jean Villeneuve (TCHEKY KARYO) who's been sent to teach the units about guerilla style warfare, Martin begins recruiting his old war buddies, such as John Billings (LEON RIPPY).

Meanwhile, Gabriel visits the hometown of his sweetheart, Anne Howard (LISA BRENNER), and gets various men to join the militia, including the town's priest, Rev. Oliver (RENE AUBERJONOIS). Rejoining forces, the father & son-led militia soon begin ambushing the British troops, singling out the officers to be the first targets. When Martin briefly meets and then fools Cornwallis into releasing a group of rebel prisoners, the enraged general gives Tavington permission to do whatever it takes - no matter the moral implications - to find and stop Martin and his activities. With the tide continually turning in the war, Tavington then sets out to do just that, hoping to preempt Martin and his men's attempts at preventing Cornwallis and the British troops from moving north through the young country.

OUR TAKE: 7 out of 10
From a marketing standpoint, most film studios - whether big or small - like to release films with a theme that's somewhat related to the time of year when they open. Done in hopes of capitalizing on the "spirit" of the moviegoers during such times, the studios regularly release horror movies and videos around Halloween, Christmas related pictures in December, and dumb summer comedies and action flicks when most students' brains have been turned off during those hot months.

The most coveted time slot in the movie biz, obviously, is the 4th of July holiday weekend (which is occasionally five days long) where the studios' "tent pole" films are released and generally make a lot of money. In keeping with the themed releases, it's somewhat surprising then that more films dealing with that American holiday and the historical events leading up to it haven't been released.

Of course, the writing, directing and producing team of Roland Emmerich and Dean Devlin unleashed the ultimate 4th of July film, "Independence Day" back in 1996, but I'm talking more about the 18th century events that led to America's freedom from British rule, rather than hostile extraterrestrials.

While countless films have focused on the American Civil War, both World Wars and the Vietnam War, relatively few have done so regarding the Revolutionary War. Whether that's due to the vast passage of time since then or is simply an unconscious reaction to the ceaseless drumming of such related information into our heads during school isn't certain, but filmmakers and moviegoers alike seem to have had little interest in seeing such matters on the big screen.

With their perfectly timed release of "The Patriot," however, Emmerich and Devlin many not only generate renewed interest in that conflict and time (especially if it's as successful as most are predicting), but may also prove that lightning indeed strikes twice as the filmmakers hope to score big once again over the holiday weekend.

This time, however, it's not Will Smith, Bill Pullman and Jeff Goldblum saving the entire planet from hostile, invading aliens. Instead it's Mel Gibson "getting medieval" once again on the British for messing up his life and ticking him off. Yes, moviegoers will no doubt see similarities between Gibson in this film and his character and performance in "Braveheart," where analogous catalysts spurred him into rebellious action and conflict with his land's oppressors.

While not quite as good or enjoyable as that Oscar-winning picture, "The Patriot" is nonetheless an entertaining - if brutal - and epic film filled with just the right amount of action, drama and even humor to appease audiences looking for some historical drama or just a good bit of escapist entertainment.

Easily the filmmaking duo's best combined effort to date (their others films include "StarGate" and "Godzilla"), the picture is grand in scale, sports mostly topnotch production values (save for some odd editing/optical work in the final battle scene), and features a good cast that delivers entertaining and mostly credible performances.

Where the film falters a bit is in length (at around 160 minutes or so) as director Emmerich doesn't always manage to maintain its forward momentum and occasionally allows the proceedings to get a bit unwieldy with too many superfluous characters. Then there's the fact that the film, its characters and their related action and dialogue occasionally feel a bit too contemporary for the setting and historical context.

While I'm certainly no expert on the history or style of the period, and the resultant effect isn't as jarring as was the case in "Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves" (where Kevin Costner repeatedly went in and out of his accent), at times, certain behavior, speech patterns and the choice of wording doesn't always seem to jive perfectly with the period.

Although some moviegoers either won't notice or care about such incongruities, others will probably agree that certain parts of the film don't feel quite right. As a result, such moments unnecessarily distract and/or pull the viewer out of the proceedings, thus further disrupting its rhythm.

Beyond that, and for the most part, the film works rather well. Of course, those looking for complete historical accuracy or the portrayal of major characters and events of the War might be a bit disappointed as the screenplay - penned by scribe Robert Rodat fresh off his Oscar nominated work on "Saving Private Ryan" - focuses on Gibson's fictitious character who's an amalgamation of various historical figures.

The plot, while also obviously fictitious to a large degree, does stick with the basic underlying historical events of the War and unfolds in a credible enough fashion for those who didn't major in the subject. Much like "Ryan" and even "Braveheart," Rodat's script also throws in a few surprises - some of them tragic - that serve to give the film a feeling of a bit more depth as well as keeping audiences guessing about the film's outcome and who might be there to participate in it.

Overall, the performances are also rather good. Portraying the torn protagonist with a troubled past, Mel Gibson ("Chicken Run," "Payback") delivers a commanding performance, notwithstanding the comedic moments he's occasionally saddled with that work but often feel a bit forced. Few actors can play the troubled but capable hero better than Gibson (think of the Mad Max and Martin Riggs characters in "The Road Warrior" and "Lethal Weapon" films), and he certainly fulfills his quota of playing a revenge-based character bound to please the vigilante in all of us.

While Gibson occasionally looks, sounds and behaves a bit too much like Mel Gibson, Heath Ledger ("10 Things I Hate About You," "Two Hands") near perfectly sinks into the role and becomes his character. Playing the eager and ambitious young patriot, Ledger delivers a winning performance, is absolutely believable, and plays well off Gibson and his character.

Portraying the polar opposites of British officers, Jason Isaacs ("Armageddon," "Event Horizon") and Tom Wilkinson ("Ride With the Devil," "The Full Monty") are good in their respective roles, with the former making a believable and worthy adversary - notwithstanding the enjoyable and seemingly purposeful chewing of the scenery -- to Gibson's reluctant, but heroic character.

Supporting performances from the likes of Joely Richardson ("Return to Me," "101 Dalmatians") and Chris Cooper ("Me, Myself & Irene," "American Beauty") are good, but Tcheky Karyo ("The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc," "Addicted to Love") easily steals the show as the humorous French officer assigned to help the rebel militia.

Although the film's highlights - its battle scenes - are somewhat similar in nature to those found in Civil War based films, they are well-staged and executed, and the guerilla-style warfare and hand-to-hand combat scenes are clearly designed to get the viewer's adrenaline pumping (and they do). That, coupled with the clear and historically and politically correct delineation of good guys and villains turns the film into a rather enthralling and entertaining time at the movies (unless, of course, you're British and don't like such characterizations).

Despite that possibility, the occasional other problems that arise, and the fact the film is bucking the trend of ignoring the Revolutionary War, "The Patriot" is a rousing, grand scale, epic film that should please most moviegoers. As such, it rates as a 7 out of 10.




Reviewed June 21, 2000 / Posted June 28, 2000


Privacy Statement and Terms of Use and Disclaimer
By entering this site you acknowledge to having read and agreed to the above conditions.

All Rights Reserved,
©1996-2023 Screen It, Inc.