[Screen It]

 

"MEAN GIRLS"
(2004) (Lindsay Lohan, Tina Fey) (PG-13)

If you've come from our parental review of this film and wish to return to it, simply click on your browser's BACK button.
Otherwise, use the following link to read our complete Parental Review of this film.

QUICK TAKE:
Comedy: After entering the public school system for the first time, a teenager tries to infiltrate the most popular clique but falls prey to its power.
PLOT:
Cady Heron (LINDSAY LOHAN) is a teenager who's entering the public school system for the first time after living in Africa where her parents worked and home-schooled her. After being introduced by North Shore High School Principal Ron Duvall (TIM MEADOWS) and math teacher Ms. Norbury (TINA FEY), Cady gets the scoop on the school and its social structure by student outsiders Janis (LIZZY CAPLAN) and Damian (DANIEL FRANZESE).

Cady thus learns of the various school cliques, including the most popular one, The Plastics, that consists of Regina George (RACHEL McADAMS), Gretchen Weiners (LACEY CHABERT) and Karen Smith (AMANDA SEYFRIED). The snobby and elitist girls take an instant liking to Cady and offer her a coveted seat with them in the cafeteria.

Realizing the Cady isn't like the rest of the Plastics, Janis and Damian think it's a prime opportunity for someone to get an inside look at the inner workings of the clique. That would include Regina's "burn book" that includes all sorts of mean, nasty and disparaging remarks about most everyone at the school.

Cady accepts the undercover mission and things seem to be going smoothly. That is, until she spots hunky Aaron Samuels (JONATHAN BENNETT) in her math class. Gretchen informs her, however, that he's Regina's ex-boyfriend and thus off limits. When Regina then purposefully sabotages any potential relationship between him and Cady, the latter sets out to turn the Plastics' lives upside down. As she does, however, she begins to fall prey to social power that her position in the clique offers.

OUR TAKE: 6 out of 10
The old saying goes that girls are made of sugar, spice, and everything nice, while boys are made of snakes, snails, and puppy-dog tails. Yeah right. While that might apply to a degree with small children, and it's true that men in general are a bit more rude and crude than women, there's always that fascinating element known as teenage girls.

Although some are fine and fairly well-adjusted, others are nasty, Lord of the Flies sorts, particularly when it comes to school and related cliques. Author Rosalind Wiseman wrote about just that and other matters in her bestselling work, "Queen Bees and Wannabes: Helping Your Daughter Survive Cliques, Gossip, Boyfriends and Other Realities of Adolescence." Now head "Saturday Night Live" writer Tina Fey and director Mark Waters ("Freaky Friday," "Head Over Heels") have adapted it into the rather funny and witty comedy, "Mean Girls."

The epitome of all such films, of course, is "Heathers," the ultra sharp black comedy featuring Winona Ryder as the newcomer who decides to off the others in her clique. In this effort -- that doesn't quite match that Michael Lehmann film in terms of overall story or dark satire -- it's Lindsay Lohan ("Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen," "Freaky Friday") who finds herself first at the mercy of the snobbish elite, then joins and eventually runs the Plastics.

The beauty of Fey's script is not only its amusing qualities, but also how the fine details and nuances of such cliques and many teenage girls work. There's the usual tormenting of the weaker species, but also the sabotage and survival of the fittest elements within the "pack."

That Lohan's character is a former home-schooled pupil who lived in Africa and occasionally envisions the students as behaving as wild beasts under the laws of the jungle only makes it that much more amusing.

And when the alpha female not so subtly tells Cady that her ex-mate, uh, boyfriend, is off limits, our protagonist sets out to get her revenge. Not jungle or even "Kill Bill" style, but instead as only teenage girls do best, and that's by slyly stabbing the others in the back and otherwise attempting to ruin their social lives.

All of which easily could have misfired or just been mundane. Thankfully, Fey (who also appears in the film as a math teacher) seems to have her pulse on the heart of teenage throes and thus hits the comedy mark far more often than she misses.

It also helps that the performances are just right. While some of the characters delve in or at least teeter around caricatures and stereotypes, there are enough novel or subtle touches to them that they don't feel recycled.

As the outsider who quickly becomes the leader of the pack, Lohan is good, once again proving she can ably play this sort of comedy, equally balancing the naive early nature of her character with the more socially malicious aspects later on.

Rachel McAdams ("The Hot Chick," "Perfect Pie"), Lacey Chabert ("Daddy Day Care," "Lost in Space") and Amanda Seyfried (making her film debut) are all decent as the other Plastics' members, although I would have liked to have seen them come off as even a bit edgier and more malicious in their social dominance. Jonathan Bennett (making his feature debut) plays the standard, hunky high school object of desire, but gets the weakest written part, while Lizzy Caplan ("Orange County") and Daniel Franzese ("Party Monster," "Hometown Legend") get some amusing moments as the school outsiders.

Various "SNL" performers -- including Fey (making her film debut), Ana Gasteyer ("What Women Want," "Woman on Top") and Amy Poehler ("Envy," "Deuce Bigalow: Male Gigolo") appear in supporting roles, but it's Tim Meadows ("The Ladies Man," "It's Pat") who's the best as the high school principal who's finally had enough with the catty remarks and behavior. While none of the major or minor characters are outstanding on their own, collectively they add up to a nice comedy mix.

With a lesser script, this easily could have been a bust in terms of social satire and/or simply generating laughs. Thankfully, and for the most part, Fey makes most of it work. While not as mean, original or funny as it might have been, and certainly not quite up to the standard established by "Heathers," "Mean Girls" is good enough to rate as a 6 out of 10.




Reviewed April 8, 2004 / Posted April 30, 2004


Privacy Statement and Terms of Use and Disclaimer
By entering this site you acknowledge to having read and agreed to the above conditions.

All Rights Reserved,
©1996-2023 Screen It, Inc.