Kenya McQueen (SANAA LATHAN) is a black senior manager at a prestigious accounting firm in Los Angeles who seems to have it all. She's poised to become a partner at her firm, she has supportive friends in the form of Cheryl (WENDY RAQUEL ROBINSON), Suzzette (GOLDEN BROOKS) and Nedra (TARAJI P. HENSON), the love of her parents Joyce (ALFRE WOODARD) and Edmond (EARL BILLINGS), and a new home.
Yet, with a long list of what she wants and needs in a man, she's single. Accordingly, a friend sets her up on a blind date, but Kenya is shocked to learn that landscape architect Brian Kelly (SIMON BAKER) is white. With him not meeting her unspoken but most important criteria, she calls off the date, but later meets him again at a wedding where, feeling guilty about the way she treated him, hires him to redo her backyard.
After working together for a while, he eventually wins her over and the two become an item. That doesn't sit well with her mother, brother Nelson (DONALD FAISON) -- who always has a different girlfriend every time she sees him -- or Cheryl's new boyfriend Walter (MIKE EPPS) who isn't sure of Brian's motives. As he and Kenya become lovers, they must deal with her and others' reactions to their mixed race relationship, as well as Nelson introducing her to the handsome and debonair Mark (BLAIR UNDERWOOD), who just so happens to be black.