[Screen It]

 

"THE DAY THE EARTH STOOD STILL"
(2008) (Keanu Reeves, Jennifer Connelly) (PG-13)

If you've come from our parental review of this film and wish to return to it, simply click on your browser's BACK button.
Otherwise, use the following link to read our complete Parental Review of this film.

QUICK TAKE:
Sci-Fi: An alien in human form, along with his enormous robot, arrive on Earth to wipe out humankind and thus save the planet, but must contend with a biologist who tries to change their minds.
PLOT:
Helen Benson (JENNIFER CONNELLY) is a professor of astrobiology at Princeton who's raising her young stepson, Jacob (JADEN SMITH), following the death of the boy's military father in the past year. Due to her credentials, but out of the blue, she's contacted and immediately picked up by the Feds and whisked away to New York City along with various other scientists and specialists. It seems a deep-space object is hurtling toward Earth and specifically Manhattan, but as everyone braces for the impact, the object slows and then lands in Central Park.

As Helen goes to meet the visitor who disembarks from the enormous sphere of a spaceship, someone in the military opens fire, downing the extraterrestrial. As a result, an enormous robot (later given the acronym G.O.R.T.) comes out and disarms the hostile forces, thus allowing Helen, her government friend Michael Granier (JON HAMM), and others to whisk the alien away for immediate medical care. And what's found under an epidermis that sloughs off is Klaatu (KEANU REEVES), the alien in human form, who quickly heals and regains both his strength and consciousness.

While the scientists are fascinated, Secretary of Defense Regina Jackson (KATHY BATES) is worried, not only because Klaatu's ship managed to avoid American military defenses, but also because he seems to have accessed most all data regarding the government and its people. Despite him wanting to address the United Nations, she's more intent on interrogating what she views as a national threat. He manages to escape, however, and having previously assessed that Helen is the only benevolent human he's encountered, he contacts her for help.

After learning that he's there to save the planet by ridding Earth of all humankind for their ecologically destructive ways, Helen, with Jacob in tow, tries to change his mind, including by taking him to visit the brilliant Professor Barnhardt (JOHN CLEESE). Yet, Regina and the rest of the government are still after him (while also attempting to dissect the impenetrable GORT), thus forcing Helen, Jacob and Klaatu to go on the run, all as she tries to convince Klaatu, before it's too late, that humans deserve a second chance.

OUR TAKE: 3.5 out of 10
Let's face it, people love to give advice to others, but don't always accept the reverse situation. After all, we're a can-do species, and there's nothing we can't solve, fix, or remedy if we put out minds, hearts and ingenuity into it. That said, we're also often desperate and/or gullible enough to seek the help of those proposing self-help remedies, but the important factor is that we decide we need such assistance rather than have them force-feed it to us.

The same holds true on a national level, where similar pride sometimes leads to rejecting advice and/or help, particularly when it comes from outsiders, and especially when some degree of threat is attached to that should we not comply. Take, for instance, back in 1951 when two foreigners with the funny names Klaatu and Gort arrived in Washington, D.C. with the dire warning about us proudly marching toward a nuclear nightmare.

We didn't ask for such advice and did what any red-blooded American would do -- we shot at them. After showing us the error of our ways, both in demonstration and with a verbal warning, they headed back home, their mission apparently complete. Yet, while we seemed to have finally heeded their warning -- at least to some degree -- about our growing stockpile of nukes, that foreign duo have returned once again. But it's not about our current economic crisis, humans' increasingly sedentary (and thus waistlines) ways, or even the unholy preponderance of "reality" TV.

No, instead it's all about the dangers of global warming and environmental pollution. This time, however, and after receiving a similarly militaristic reception from the Yanks, they've apparently decided enough is enough and are ready to deploy generous amounts of pesticide -- ironically enough, in the form of little metal insect-like creatures -- to rid the Earth of its main pests -- us!!!

The first time around, of course, was covered in the seminal 1951 sci-fi classic, "The Day the Earth Stood Still." Directed by Robert Wise and adapted from Harry Bates' story "Farewell to the Master" by screenwriter Edmund H. North, the film was a terrific, cold war cautionary tale with cool special effects (for the time) that still stands up fairly well today, at least when viewed as a more than half century old pic.

Never one to leave well enough alone, Hollywood has decided to remake the movie with the same title, but a change in focus from nukes to greenhouse gases and such. The result, while containing some equally cool (if technologically updated) special effects, is a pale imitator of its predecessor. Simply put, things don't make sense, we don't care about the characters or the outcome, and the writing -- that was so superb the first time around -- is so bad that such extraterrestrial aliens might just do a drive-by to perform a mercy killing of our apparently intellectually slipping species.

Beyond said effects (that ultimately become redundant and aren't really anything new that we haven't seen before), the one thing this pic has going for it is the casting of Keanu Reeves taking over the Klaatu character populated last time by Michael Rennie.

While I've often liked Reeves in certain roles, there's no denying he sometimes delivers emotionally cool and some might say vacant performances that make him seem, well, like an alien in human form, trying to fit in with the proper emotions, but coming off somewhat robotic and artificial. Since that's what he's playing here, it's a perfect match. Alas, director Scott Derrickson and screenwriter David Scarpa don't take enough advantage of that to make it pay off, and they've even jettisoned everyone's favorite line from the original, "Klaatu barada nikto!"

The bigger issue, however, is that so much of the film fails or simply mystifies in its logic or lack thereof. After arriving and getting the traditional bullet welcome, Klaatu does the old "take me to your leader" bit, except this time he wants to deliver his big speech to the U.N. Yet, and despite having supernatural powers that allow him to take out military attacks (much like his more robotic and far larger than last time companion who gets an acronym as his name rather than arriving with that already attached), he spends most of the film running around in the woods with an incredibly wooden, but still quite pretty Jennifer Connolly and her annoying brat of a stepson played by Jaden Smith.

I understand that there's the requisite human exposure and inevitable bonding (by the way, done so much better in the far superior "Terminator 2," especially considering the scene where the alien finally realizes humans might not be so bad after all), but if the "apply pesticide" decision has already been made, why bother arriving and informing everyone of their pending doom? Are these aliens sadists as well, like human kids moving a magnifying glass around an ant before incinerating him in a focused beam of sunlight?

That, and a number of other questionable character and filmmaker motives and decisions end up bedeviling the production, shifting the viewer's focus from worrying about the characters (not to mention the plight of the world) to scratching their heads (thus taking them out of the action) and making them think about far better alien invasion flicks such as Spielberg's "War of the Worlds" or, better yet, "Close Encounters of the Third Kind."

What's then left is a simple curiosity about what the special effects team is going to destroy, much has occurred in other contemporary disaster flicks ("The Day After Tomorrow," anyone?) where the money shots are landmarks getting wiped out in some spectacular way. Sadly, only those who hate the New York Giants will likely find any sort of satisfaction in what's offered (and to tell you the truth, the IMAX logo teaser that opens the film -- in, naturally, IMAX equipped theaters -- is far more impressive than most anything the filmmakers have dreamed up).

Slow to develop and unfold, filled with two when not one-dimensional characters (what was Kathy Bates thinking?), and running off an incredibly weak screenplay that should have siphoned off some of the special effects budget to make it better, "The Day the Earth Stood Still" redux isn't worth sitting still to watch (and that's our advice whether you want it or not). It rates as a boring 3.5 out of 10.




Reviewed December 9, 2008 / Posted December 12, 2008


Privacy Statement and Terms of Use and Disclaimer
By entering this site you acknowledge to having read and agreed to the above conditions.

All Rights Reserved,
©1996-2023 Screen It, Inc.