[Screen It]

 

"GHOSTS OF GIRLFRIENDS PAST"
(2009) (Matthew McConaughey, Jennifer Garner) (PG-13)

If you've come from our parental review of this film and wish to return to it, simply click on your browser's BACK button.
Otherwise, use the following link to read our complete Parental Review of this film.

QUICK TAKE:
Romantic Comedy: While attending his brother's wedding, a confirmed bachelor and habitual womanizer ends up haunted by ghosts determined to show him the error of his ways.
PLOT:
Fashion photographer Connor Mead (MATTHEW McCONAUGHEY) is at the top of his game. While his assistant, Melanie (NOUREEN DeWULF), handles his scheduling and business affairs, he usually ends up bedding his lingerie models, following the advice of his late Uncle Wayne (MICHAEL DOUGLAS) in terms of getting women in bed but never committing to any of them.

Accordingly, he really isn't in favor of his younger brother, Paul (BRECKIN MEYER), marrying Sandra (LACEY CHABERT), but agrees to be the best man at their wedding. Besides, it allows him to see the various bridesmaids, all but one of which he's previously bedded. That includes Jenny Perotti (JENNIFER GARNER), a physician and the only woman who nearly got him by the heart after knowing each other since they were kids.

She isn't crazy to see Connor, which also holds true for Sandra's father, Sergeant Volkom (ROBERT FORSTER), a Korean War vet who will be officiating at the ceremony. But that also means his sexy ex-wife, Vondra (ANNE ARCHER), will be in attendance, much to the delight of Connor.

He's less thrilled, however, and actually quite shocked, to have an encounter with Uncle Wayne who informs him that he'll be visited by three other ghosts -- from Connor's past, present and future -- who will show him the error of his womanizing ways. Connor thinks his uncle is an alcohol-fueled hallucination until he finds Allison Vandermeersh (EMMA STONE) in his bed. She's the teenager to whom he lost his virginity, and she takes him on a tour of his past behavior, while Mel does the same for his present, and another Ghost (OLGA MALIOUK) does the future bit.

As he contends with that, he must also deal with his resurrected feelings for Jenny who wants little to do with him, especially considering the presence of the handsome and debonair Brad (DANIEL SUNJATA) who's been flown in by the bride for Jenny's enjoyment.

OUR TAKE: 3 out of 10
It's been 166 years since Charles Dickens wrote "A Christmas Carol," the classic tale of a miserable man who gets his outlook on life rebooted, if you will, by visits from three ghosts. Those from the past, present and future show him the errors of his ways including the damage he's done and the potential ultimate results of his behavior.

In the intervening century and a half plus, others have used that story as a template for telling similar tales, and with each one, you have to wonder about Dickens' reaction. Is he looking down and smiling at what he inspired (and perhaps gloating a bit over his legacy continuing on for so long) or, as they like to say, is he spinning in his grave over the injustice and/or bastardization done to his work?

Considering how "Ghosts of Girlfriends Past" plays out, I'm guessing it's probably the latter. Yet another film where Matthew McConaughey embodies a "player" who's loath to settle down, this rip-off of "Christmas Carol" retrofits it as a wake-up call for a womanizer like Connor Mead. While the film might play okay to less-discerning viewers and offers a smattering of laughs, it generally has a dim view of women (despite the player getting his comeuppance), has a fairly shoddy construction, and generally doesn't make you care one iota about the lothario for good or bad.

McConaughey plays a famous photographer best known for shooting fashion models in next to nothing before bedding and then immediately casting them off to move on to his next conquest. While there was one girl (Jennifer Garner as the adult version) who entranced him for years, he similarly bedded and discarded her off like the rest, following the rules laid out before him by his similarly minded mentor uncle (Michael Douglas).

But the latter has returned -- from beyond the grave, no less -- to warn his nephew to change his ways or else, and states that he'll be visited by three ghosts (sound familiar?). And this just so happens to occur the night before his younger brother (Breckin Meyer) is getting married (to Lacey Chabert) and where Connor has previously bedded all but one of the bridesmaids including, natch, the one played by Garner.

That's followed by those three personal tour guide spirits (Emma Stone, Noureen DeWulf and Olga Maliouk) taking him through the standard motions of the tale, his eyes are opened, and he then races to fix everything he's screwed up, including the wedding as well as his on-again, off-again involvement with Jenny.

While clearly not original any way one looks at it, the material does have some potential, however limited it might be. Alas, helmer Mark Waters -- whose directing efforts have been hit or miss affairs and works here from a script by Jon Lucas and Scott Moore who helped pen the similarly awful "Four Christmases" -- simply can't do much of anything to make us care or even just entertain viewers.

The comedy often feels forced and the timing off, with the story sort of meandering about within the confines of its pre-built parameters. And none of it shines whether in flashbacks (that take up the bulk of the supernatural material where present-day Connor gets to see his younger self fail with girls, be tutored by his uncle, and then transform into a player), a brief, out of body present day view of his effects on the heartbroken, or an even briefer future look at his obviously lonely demise.

McConaughey does his usual stuff (albeit only once appearing shirtless by my count) and if you've liked that in the past, you'll likely have the same reaction to his work here (although the charmed that's carried him before is running dry). Garner is completely wasted, while Breckin Meyer and Lacey Chabert don't contribute much worth noting (enough with the hysterical bride shtick already).

Douglas comes off like he's slumming it here (although you still have to love that smooth vocal delivery), and the ladies playing the spirits can't do much with their parts. Even considering the "Christmas Carol" trajectory, there's never any doubt about how things will play out, thus making the overall experience even more of a chore to sit through. "Ghosts of Girlfriends Past" rates as a 3 out of 10.




Reviewed April 28, 2009 / Posted May 1, 2009


Privacy Statement and Terms of Use and Disclaimer
By entering this site you acknowledge to having read and agreed to the above conditions.

All Rights Reserved,
©1996-2023 Screen It, Inc.